The Invisible Mentor

I interviewed a business coach and asked him what his favourite quote was. He responded that he had two favourite quotes. I will focus on one quote to demonstrate a point. My interviewee said that the quote was often attributed to Einstein, but he had seen variations of the quote. He wanted to find out definitively who the quote was by. The quote is “Insanity is doing the same thing over and over but expecting to get a different result.” I did a quick search on the Internet and here is what I found:

“Insanity is doing the same thing over and over but expecting to get a different result” Albert Einstein

“The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over but expecting to get a different result” Benjamin Franklin

Now we have a dilemma because these are the same quote. I called the library’s answer line and asked them to check their quotations reference books to see who the quote was attributed to. Either version of the quote wasn’t in any of the reference books that they checked.

I went to the reference library and conducted some additional research. I found “The New Quotable Einstein” by Alice Calaprice, senior editor at Princeton University Press. I went through the entire book manually because there was no way to do it electronically, and I couldn’t find the quote. I contacted the author and explained the situation. Alice Calaprice is an Einstein expert and is very familiar with, and has access to the “Einstein Papers.” She responded that she had never seen that quote in all the years that she had been researching Einstein, and that there are many quotes on insanity and genius that people love to attribute to Einstein though he rarely used those words.

Should I assume that the quote must be by Benjamin Franklin? Not likely! I have not been able to find a definitive answer so whenever I use the quote I say popularly attributed to Einstein and Franklin. The point I wanted to illustrate to you is that because several people are citing information and attributing it to a source, doesn’t mean that the information is accurate. It simply means that they are all citing from the one source so you have to exercise some due diligence. Though this wasn’t a paid project, I have worked on other projects where this same issue arose. Would you be willing to put in the time and effort to find the correct answer? If you have ever faced this dilemma please let me know how you handled it.

Related Post

How to Analyze Information

No related posts.

One Response to “Because Everyone is Saying It, Doesn’t Make It Right”